5 - Reporter's Privilege

Reporter's Privilege

When first beginning this project, I wasn’t really sure what Reporter’s Privilege was. When taking the time to research, I have learned that reporters are granted the right to remain silent in court when asked about confidential information from their news publications. In 2002, the Reporter’s Privilege Compendium was posted online and became the most thoroughly detailed explanation of Reporter's Privilege. This was put out not only for reporters but also for lawyers who are hired to get journalists out of a subpoena. The idea to come up with this Compendium came from the instance when Vanessa Leggett, an unpublished author, was writing a story about a murder that occured in Houston and later on went to jail because she refused to identify the names of the people who gave her the information in her book. Leggett spent 168 days in jail, still refusing to name the names and said she would do it all over again if need be. This was the longest time any American journalist had been in jail. Leggett was only released from jail when the grand jury she was supposed to testify in front of expired. She received much praise from journalists amid her release as journalists believed that it is their right to be able to classify the sources that they received their information from. While Reporter’s Privilege is a thing in many states, Leggett went to jail due to the fact that reporter's privilege is not a thing in the fifth circuit of the federal court which includes Texas, where Leggett was writing her story from. 

Additionally, the U.S. department of Justice couldn’t get involved with the matter because of the fact that Leggett technically isn’t considered a journalist, she’s an unpublished author. Depending on where the reporter's privilege is discussed really determines how it comes into effect. For example in some cases, reporter's privilege will be argued to be a constitutional right while in other cases, reporter's privilege is referred to as a statute passed by legislature. In some cases it can cover non confidential information while in other cases it doesn't. This is where the lines become blurry when discussing reporter's privilege because while it is a universally accepted idea, the concept of the regulation is not concrete. This being the case, some lawyers and journalists don’t even know what reporter's privilege is and because of this they don’t know how to combat being subpoenaed. The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press decided that something needed to be done about this and that they would do something about this. That is when they decided to put together the “Reporter’s Privilege Compendium”. The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press discusses how priest-penitent, doctor-patient, and client-lawyer confidentiality is respected, why would the relationship between a journalist and the people they interview or convene with be any different? All of these relationships demonstrate a certain type of professionalism and should be regarded as so which I completely agree with. 

     In 1972, case Branzbury v. Hayes was the one and only case in which the U.S. The Supreme Court viewed reporter's privilege as a constitutional principle rather than an informal idea. During this court case, Justice Potter Stewart brought it to the attention that journalists should be allowed a qualifying privilege and that, “courts should consider whether the information is “clearly relevant” and material to the party’s case, whether there is “a compelling and overriding interest in the information,” and whether the information could be obtained from any source other than the media.”

     After studying reporter's privilege and taking the time to see what it means, I feel that this is definitely a principle that needs to be addressed on a wider scale. The privilege needs to be cemented in legislature in all states and districts so there is no possible miscommunication or remolding of the terms. This isn’t just important for the journalists that are subpoenaed but it’s also important for those like lawyers who need to know how to best take a stance on representing their clients and jury’s who need to know if the principle they’re taking into consideration is constitutionally based on opinionatedly based.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

10 - Freedom of Information Act

9 - Global Media Law or Ethics